how to respond to a low personal injury settlement offer

Steps to Respond to a Low Settlement Offer

• Remain Calm. Receiving a lowball settlement offer for your pain and suffering can feel insulting, but you owe it to yourself not to react emotionally to an initial offer.
• Analyze the Offer. After receiving an offer, you and your attorney will analyze its contents. ...
• Develop a Counteroffer. ...
• Respond in Writing. ...
• Don’t Settle Until You’ve Healed. ...

Full Answer

Why did I receive a low settlement offer from my attorney?

If you are represented by a personal injury attorney for your injuries and they have already sent the initial demand letter for your claim, you may receive a low settlement offer from an insurance company, or the law firm representing the at-fault party.

Should I accept a low settlement offer for my car accident claim?

When you add the emotional trauma of motor vehicle accident injuries on top of these economic costs, a low settlement offer for your personal injury claim from the at-fault party’s insurance company feels like nothing more than an insult. Fortunately, you do not have to accept a low offer.

Why is it important to respond to a settlement offer?

Your response to this initial settlement offer will go a long way toward determining whether you'll end up with a fair outcome. (Get the basics on writing your personal injury demand letter ).

How do I respond to an insurance adjuster’s settlement offer?

Learn more about how an insurance adjuster comes up with a settlement offer. Before writing a formal response, you can call or email the adjuster and ask several specific questions in order to evaluate the basis for the low initial offer.

How do you reject and respond to a low insurance settlement offer?

Countering a Low Insurance Settlement OfferState that the offer you received is unacceptable.Refute any statements in the adjustor's letter that are inaccurate and damaging to your claim.Re-state an acceptable figure.Explain why your counteroffer is appropriate, including the reasons behind your general damages demands.More items...•

How do you counter offer a Personal Injury settlement?

From the standpoint of procedure, you will need to make a counter-offer in writing. Be sure you send your letter to the appropriate person, whether that be an insurance adjuster or an attorney. Make it clear that you are rejecting their initial offer and include your reasons for doing so.

What do I do if my insurance offer is too low?

Here are five steps to take if the insurance company is lowballing you:Get Help from an Attorney. ... Make Sure It Is Actually a Lowball Offer. ... Figure Out Why the Insurance Company Is Lowballing You. ... Collect the Evidence You Need to Prove Your Claim. ... Keep Negotiating and/or File a Lawsuit in Court.

Can you negotiate a settlement offer?

While you can negotiate a settlement with a creditor at any time, debt settlement agencies require your accounts to go delinquent for 90 days—and sometimes more—before they will begin negotiating.

Should I accept first offer of compensation?

Unless you have taken independent legal advice on the whole value of your claim, you should not accept a first offer from an insurance company.

How do insurance companies negotiate cash settlements?

Let's look at how to best position your claim for success.Have a Settlement Amount in Mind. ... Do Not Jump at a First Offer. ... Get the Adjuster to Justify a Low Offer. ... Emphasize Emotional Points. ... Put the Settlement in Writing. ... More Information About Negotiating Your Personal Injury Claim.

How do you ask for more money in a settlement?

Send a Detailed Demand Letter to the Insurance Company Because the insurance company will likely reply with an offer for an amount lower than what you've asked for in the demand letter, you should ask for between 25 and 100 percent more than what you would be willing to settle for.

How do you negotiate a settlement with an insurance claims adjuster?

Begin the Settlement Negotiation Process (5 Steps)Step 1: File An Insurance Claim. ... Step 2: Consolidate Your Records. ... Step 3: Calculate Your Minimum Settlement Amount. ... Step 4: Reject the Claims Adjuster's First Settlement Offer. ... Step 5: Emphasize The Strongest Points in Your Favor.

How do you negotiate a total loss payout?

Summary: How to negotiate the best settlement for your totaled carKnow what you are selling to your car insurance company.Prepare your counter offer.Determine the comparables (comps) in the area.Obtain a written settlement offer from the auto insurance company.Make your counteroffer for your totaled car.

How much should I offer in a settlement agreement?

The rough 'rule of thumb' that is generally used to determine the value of a settlement agreement (in respect of compensation for termination of employment) is two to three months' gross salary.

Is it better to settle or pay in full?

Settling for Less Can Relieve Stress And it's important to know that paying your debt in full is the better option when it comes to your credit. If you can't pay in full, settling is better than defaulting on your debt and may relieve some stress for you.

What is a reasonable full and final settlement offer?

It depends on what you can afford, but you should offer equal amounts to each creditor as a full and final settlement. For example, if the lump sum you have is 75% of your total debt, you should offer each creditor 75% of the amount you owe them.

How do you write a counter offer letter?

Tips for Writing a Counteroffer LetterState clear reasons backed with research. ... Communicate other job offers. ... Emphasize your sought-after skills. ... Formulate your wants as requests rather than demands. ... Use polite, neutral terms. ... Edit and proofread.

How do you negotiate a settlement with an insurance claims adjuster?

Begin the Settlement Negotiation Process (5 Steps)Step 1: File An Insurance Claim. ... Step 2: Consolidate Your Records. ... Step 3: Calculate Your Minimum Settlement Amount. ... Step 4: Reject the Claims Adjuster's First Settlement Offer. ... Step 5: Emphasize The Strongest Points in Your Favor.

How do I ask for insurance for more money?

Send a Detailed Demand Letter to the Insurance Company Because the insurance company will likely reply with an offer for an amount lower than what you've asked for in the demand letter, you should ask for between 25 and 100 percent more than what you would be willing to settle for.

How do I write a counter offer for an auto accident settlement?

Prepare Your Counter-Offer The letter should include: A summary of the initial offer that was sent to you and explain why that was too low or not fully representing your injuries and costs.. Research and calculations to validate why you think it is too low. (i.e. the sum of special and general damages).

What happens after a personal injury?

In a typical personal injury case, after the nature and extent of your injuries and other losses (your " damages ") become known, you (or your lawyer if you have one) will send a demand letter sent to the person responsible for the injuries, or to that person's insurance company. In this article, let's assume you're dealing with an insurance ...

Why is my insurance offer low?

The initial low offer may be due to insufficient information about your injuries or other claimed losses. If this is the case, provide the adjuster with itemized and updated medical bills, proof of lost income, and other relevant records.

What does "low ball" mean in an insurance demand letter?

The insurance company may respond to your demand letter with an unreasonable ("low-ball") settlement offer. Your response to this initial settlement offer will go a long way toward determining whether you'll end up with a fair outcome.

How much is a reasonable counteroffer?

A reasonable counteroffer may be between $30,000 and $35,000. As you might expect, there may be more than one counteroffer in a personal injury case. It may seem like a waste of time, but this kind of back-and-forth is a standard part of the personal injury settlement process.

Is it a mistake to accept a low personal injury settlement offer?

It's usually a mistake to fire back with a quick emotional response to a low personal injury settlement offer, and it can be an even bigger mistake to accept it. You may be upset, or in need of money, but it's important to maintain a professional relationship with the other side—whether it's a defense attorney or an insurance claims adjuster. Remember that the initial offer by an insurance company is typically just a starting point for settlement negotiations. Learn more about how an insurance adjuster comes up with a settlement offer.

Can you go back after an accident?

Once you accept the settlement and sign a release, you can't go back and file a personal injury lawsuit or otherwise ask for more money.

Is it a good idea to respond to a low personal injury settlement offer with an unreasonably high?

It's never a good idea to respond to a low personal injury settlement offer with an unreasonably -high counteroffer. Again, it's important to maintain a professional and detailed approach to personal injury settlement negotiations. Consider the amount you think you deserve, the limits of the applicable insurance coverage, and the at-fault party's potential assets. Based on your injuries, you may feel that you deserve $40,000. However, the other side may have low insurance policy limits. In this case, the insurance company may offer $20,000. A reasonable counteroffer may be between $30,000 and $35,000.

What If My Insurance Settlement Is Too Low?

When you accept an insurance settlement, you agree not to pursue additional compensation from whoever caused the accident. So, if you take a settlement offer that’s too low, you most likely won’t be able to get any more money if you need it.

How Should I Respond to a Low Settlement Offer?

If you get an unfairly low settlement offer, that does not mean your case is over, or you have no options. Instead, after receiving the offer, talk to a lawyer and take the following steps:

How to Respond to a Low Settlement Offer

Always respond to a low settlement offer in writing rather than over the phone or in person. Submitting a counteroffer in writing gives you a chance to provide more evidence to support your claim. If you haven’t already hired a lawyer, do so before you respond to the low offer you received.

Should I File a Personal Injury Lawsuit?

Sometimes the threat of a lawsuit is enough to bring insurance companies back to the table, as they know trials are risky. In other cases, though, insurance companies will dig in their heels and take their chances in court. If your case does go to trial, you need to get help from an experienced trial lawyer.

How a Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help You Negotiate a Settlement

Hiring a personal lawyer gives you the best chance of getting a fair insurance settlement. Your attorney can help you document your other losses, file your claim, and handle all the correspondence with the insurance companies while you rest and heal.

How You Need to Respond

If you’ve been working on your claim up until now, the best thing to do is to speak with our attorneys at Osterbauer to get the assistance and advice you need. An experienced and knowledgeable personal injury attorney will be able to represent you and fight for your best interests.

Stay Calm

If you’ve been given a lowball offer for your suffering and pain, it may feel like an insult but you need to remain calm and avoid reacting to this initial offer. Because you have no obligation to talk to the insurer, you will need to keep a professional approach and leave the negotiation with your attorney.

Analyze their Offer

After getting an offer, you can look through its content along with your attorney. He/she will be able to break everything down for you and check what is and isn’t acceptable which you can then use in making the counteroffer.

Ask Questions

Once you’ve had the time to analyze their offer and are no longer letting emotions take control, it’s time to start asking questions. Be sure to find out why the adjuster provided that specific offer and ask your claims adjuster to provide you with a breakdown of how the offer was made based on the details they have.

Provide Facts

When trying to settle offers regarding injuries, everything will need to be documented, so be sure to gather information on the following things:

Create Your Counteroffer

Apart from providing them with a formal rejection of their offer, you and your attorney can create a counteroffer based on the amount of compensation you deserve, which may include:

Respond in Writing

Your attorney can create a formal response to notify the insurer that you will not be accepting their offer. While your attorney creates a draft, you and your attorney can point out any assumptions being made by the insurance company that resulted in the low offer.

Use this sample as a guide in crafting your own response to the insurance company's unreasonably low injury settlement offer

Use this sample as a guide in crafting your own response to the insurance company's unreasonably low injury settlement offer.

Free Case Evaluation

Please answer a few questions to help us match you with attorneys in your area.

What happens if a plaintiff refuses a settlement offer?

In some states, if a defendant makes a settlement offer that the plaintiff refuses, and the plaintiff's damages award at trial are equal to or less than the settlement offer, the plaintiff will be required to pay the defendant's attorney fees and court costs. Depending on how complicated the case was, even though the plaintiff "won," he or she may have to pay more to the defendant than the defendant is required to pay in damages! Therefore, a plaintiff should be wary about automatically refusing a reasonable first settlement offer.

Who makes settlement offer in a lawsuit?

Once a complaint has been filed, a settlement offer, if any, will be made by either the defendant or the defendant's insurance company.

What happens if a plaintiff is unrepresented by an attorney?

If a plaintiff is unrepresented by an attorney and hasn't developed the case by gathering facts (or worse, doesn't even know how to do so), an insurance company or represented defendant will most likely give a settlement offer that is low relative to the potential damages.

What happens if the insurance company knows that the plaintiff is desperate for cash and/or new to the litigation process?

If the insurance company or defendant knows that the plaintiff is desperate for cash and/or new to the litigation process, the offer will be even lower.

What happens if a defendant has little cash?

If a defendant has little cash and few assets, a plaintiff is not going to get much out of a trial, no matter how big the damage award. If a settlement offer from a broke defendant isn't much less than what a plaintiff could hope to collect after a trial, settling and avoiding the hassle could be the best course.

What is the key consideration in a lawsuit?

The key consideration is what the defendant's insurance policy limits are. A defendant will have to pay out of pocket for any damage awards that go beyond the policy limit, so if the policy limit is low and the defendant is broke, a seemingly low settlement offer might be as good as it gets. If the policy limit is high, the plaintiff will not need to consider how much money is available to pay a potential damage award, and can focus on other factors.

Can a plaintiff get stung by a settlement?

However, the unwary plaintiff could get stung by litigation settlement rules, depending on the state.

Short Answer

You respond to a low personal injury settlement by reviewing the offer with a lawyer. They will tell you what they think of your case during a free consultation and how they would pursue the legal aspects of your case.

Five Steps for Responding to a Low Injury Settlement Offer

Every case follows a different process. However, there are some general steps that many negotiated claims follow, including getting legal advice, issuing a new settlement demand, and counter arguing. There are matters where the insurer refuses to face facts and will not pay a fair settlement, which means that you may have to take them to court.

You Have the Right to Hold Out for a Fair Settlement

Settling too quickly could cost you tens of thousands of dollars in unanticipated losses. Federal and state laws would protect your legal right to a fair award if someone else’s negligence caused your injuries.

WHAT TO DO AFTER A SERIOUS CAR ACCIDENT

You should fully expect that the insurance company will make a low settlement offer the first time they contact you. You can start preparing for that possibility immediately after your accident by:

ECONOMIC VS NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES

The damage from a car accident can affect multiple aspects of your daily life. Economic damages relate to a specific monetary harm such as medical expenses or lost wages. Non economic damages are more intangible losses, and as such, are much more difficult to assign a value to.

WHY DO INSURANCE COMPANIES UNDERVALUE PAIN AND SUFFERING CLAIMS?

It is almost never in the best interest of the insurance company to help you understand your rights, or how valuable your claim may be following a car accident.

HOW TO DETERMINE PAIN AND SUFFERING

What exactly do pain and suffering damages cover? This can be a tricky question, and victims often undervalue their own pain and suffering, at their own expense. When your injuries result in a decrease in your ability to perform or enjoy activities of daily life, the toll on your overall health and mental well being can be difficult to quantify.

HOW DO INSURANCE COMPANIES TRY TO AVOID PAYING FOR SERVICES?

Insurance companies have several strategies they will use when offering you a low settlement, in an effort to get you to accept. They may:

HOW TO RESPOND TO A LOW SETTLEMENT OFFER

Once you have received a settlement offer by phone or email, take the time to compare it to your records to determine if you feel the offer is fair and will properly cover your costs. Then you can determine how to respond to the low settlement offer.

HOW A PERSONAL INJURY LAWYER CAN HELP YOU REJECT A LOWBALL SETTLEMENT OFFER

The mere presence of a lawyer’s letterhead on a letter rejecting a lowball settlement offer can alter the way that insurance agencies handle your claim. And in the case that you wish to proceed with a lawsuit, you will have already been working with a lawyer who understands the particulars of your case.

How to reject a settlement offer?

To reject the initial offer, you will create a counteroffer and send it via mail to the insurance company claims adjuster. This letter should state: 1 That you will not accept the initial settlement offer; 2 The reasons why you feel you deserve a higher settlement amount; 3 Each of their low-offer reasons, and your responses; 4 The higher settlement amount that you will accept.

How to counter an insurance settlement offer?

When you receive the initial settlement offer in writing, examine the reasons the insurance adjuster has given for the low settlement amount . Each of these points will become a part of your counteroffer letter, and you should respond to each and every one. Your counteroffer letter will reassert your original position described in your demand letter, as well as respond to each of their low-offer reasons in turn. Keep your emotions out of the letter and stick to facts, such as the extreme pain and suffering you have had to endure and the frustration and hassle of attending medical treatments. Be professional, courteous, and confident, and never attack the claims adjuster personally in your counteroffer letter.

What is a lowball offer from an insurance adjuster?

The initial offer you receive from the insurance adjuster will almost always be a "lowball" offer. They may defend their low offer by claiming that you were partially at fault for the accident that caused your injuries, or that the injuries you suffered weren't severe enough to warrant a greater amount. They may also question the amount of pain and suffering you experienced. They will aggressively defend their position of a low offer because this will often intimidate people into simply accepting the low offer. Do not ever accept the initial offer unless it is a fair offer.

How to reject an insurance offer?

To reject the initial offer, you will create a counteroffer and send it via mail to the insurance company claims adjuster. This letter should state:

What happens after an insurance adjuster investigates a personal injury claim?

After the insurance company has fully investigated your personal injury claim, they will make their first offer of settlement. Their investigation may include witness interviews, examination of the police reports and medical records pertinent to your case, and the demand letter you've forwarded to them. By the time the insurance adjuster presents an offer, they will feel confident about who was liable for the injuries you've suffered and property damage incurred, and what those are worth as a dollar amount.

What to do in a counteroffer letter?

Your counteroffer letter will reassert your original position described in your demand letter, as well as respond to each of their low-offer reasons in turn. Keep your emotions out of the letter and stick to facts, such as the extreme pain and suffering you have had to endure and the frustration and hassle of attending medical treatments.

How long does it take to get a settlement offer from insurance?

The initial settlement offer that comes from the insurance company can come at any time after you've filed your claim . Some personal injury claimants have to wait weeks to receive the offer, and some receive it rather quickly. Unfortunately, there is no set time in which the initial offer must be made.