Many people over the years have argued the Treaty of Versailles was a fair peace settlement for the following reasons: ❖ They believed Germany only said that it was unable to meet the terms because it wanted to escape punishment. ❖ They thought it punished the defeated countries but gave them the opportunity to recover.
Was the Treaty of Versailles a fair Treaty?
Was the treaty of Versailles fair? The treaty of Versailles was signed in 1919 after the World War one. It was actually a punishment of Germany to start the war and forced it to accept all the blame. The involved requirements were seen to be very harsh.
How did the Germans feel about the Treaty of Versailles?
The Germans believed that the peace would be settled fairly and that it would be based on the 14 points. However, the armistice included harsh terms, and the fact that none of the defeated nations were allowed representatives at Versailles, should have been a warning of the kind of peace that Germany could expect.
Was Versailles wise or unwise?
Versailles wise or unwise. The Treaty was fair in the sense that it could be justified by the Allied powers. It was not wise in that the harsh conditions of the treaty set the stage for world war II. Germany had declared war on France Russia and England after Russia declared war on the Austrian Hungarian Empire.
What were the terms of the Treaty of Versailles and Neuilly?
The Treaty of Versailles was signed in June 1919, and officially ended the war between the Allies and Germany. The Treaty of St Germain(p.0)was signed in September 1919, and officially ended the war between the Allies and Austria. The Treaty of Neuilly(p.0)was signed in November 1919, and officially ended the war between the Allies and Bulgaria.
Was the Versailles Settlement fair?
The Versailles Settlement was controversial when it was created and historians still disagree over whether it was just.
What was considered fair about the Versailles Settlement?
Many people over the years have argued the Treaty of Versailles was a fair peace settlement for the following reasons:...
What was considered unfair about the Versailles Settlement?
There were 9 significant reasons the Versailles Settlement was considered unfair. ❖...
Was the Treaty of Versailles a harsh peace?
This lack of enforcement caused this desperate act from the French and proves that the Treaty of Versailles wasn’t a harsh peace. Another factor th...
What ways was the Treaty of Versailles too harsh?
The Treaty of Versailles was Too Harsh on Germany EssayWas World War 2 Justified Essay. Was World War II a continuation of World War I? Treaty of V...
What was the Treaty of Versailles and what it does?
The treaty called for:demilitarization and occupation of the Rhinelandspecial status for the Saarland under French controlreferendums to determine...
How justified was the Treaty of Versailles?
Here’s why:Germany and Austria Hungary were friends, and neither were expecting a war.The Austrian-Hungarian Empire looked south and wanted to unif...
What was the Treaty of Versailles?
The treaty of Versailles was signed in 1919 after the World War one. It was actually a punishment of Germany to start the war and forced it to accept all the blame. The involved requirements were seen to be very harsh. Many arguments were made on the treaty, and the most common question was that whether the treaty of Versailles fair. In my opinion, I am quite agreeing with the decision. Firstly, there is no fair in warfare. Defeat powers should obey the victors’ orders unconditionally, no excuse, and no complaint, just accepting the lost. Secondly, the treaty of Versailles was made by the “ Big Three”, they were Woodrow Wilson from America, Lloyd George from Britain and Clemenceau from French. The terms in the treaty were put up by those three ideas. Their different attitudes and opinions were restricting the others. Nobody would be completely satisfied and also no one could make it extremely harsh or kind. Thirdly, relating the cost of the war. This is also the most important point of my view. In World War 1, numbers of villages and towns were destroyed. The economy and industry in Europe collapsed. From every nation who took part in there barely was a family who hadn't lost a member, nearly 35 million casualties, including a large amount of death of innocent people. How could Germany and her allies pay for this? The treaty of Versailles was deserved. In the treaty, Germany was asked to pay a huge amount of reparations, up to 6600 millions. Some people thought it was very unreasonable. At the time, it was impossible for Germany, but it was not given a time limit. Germany can rebuild the economy step by step till finally being able to pay off the compensation payment. Germen were also very angry about the arrangement of the territories. As a defeated country, there was no doubt Germany need to give back all the colonies, and be planed just as it did to the other country before.
How long did it take Germany to recover from the war?
The aim of it was to weaken the German power and ensure there was no any more war, nevertheless Germany regained the power in 20 years, rebuilt the industry and military. Germany recovered very fast from the lost.
What was the Paris Peace Conference?
The Paris Peace Conference 1919. decide on peace terms offered to Central Powers. Sign peace treaties with them. Russia – Although it had fought with Allies, surrendered to Germany in 1917. Many Allied leaders distrusted new Bolshevik govt. Central Powers - Not consulted about terms of treaty.
When in the year 1919 the German people was burdened with the Peace Treaty, should we have been justified in?
When in the year 1919 the German people was burdened with the peace treaty, we should have been justified in hoping that precisely through this instrument of boundless repression the cry for German freedom would have been immensely promoted.
Why did France and Belgium send troops into the Ruhr?
By 1923 France and Belgium sent troops into the Ruhr to seize goods in replacement for reparations. The Weimar Government organised a campaign of passive resistance and paid the Ruhr workers not to work. However, they did not have the money for this, and so printed even more, which led to hyperinflation.
What was the situation in 1919?
The situation in 1919 was too complex . Many questions relating to self-determination were almost impossible for the big three to solve - allowed Plebiscites (leaving it up to others to decide)
What did the Germans believe about the peace?
The Germans believed that the peace would be settled fairly and that it would be based on the 14 points. However, the armistice included harsh terms, and the fact that none of the defeated nations were allowed representatives at Versailles, should have been a warning of the kind of peace that Germany could expect.
Why did the Big Three not get everything they wanted?
NB: The big three did not get everything they wanted because they allowed other people to make the decisions.
How long did the French have access to Saar coal?
Unrestricted French access to Saar Coal (8% of German output before 1914) region administered by League of Nations for 15 years with a plebiscite to follow.
Why was Germany humilliated by the Treaty of Versailles?
Germany was humilliated by the Treaty of Versailles and the harsh conditions it imposed explains much the resentment towards the winners of WWI which made Hitler's victory possible.
What was Germany guilty of?
Germany had been guilty of executions and harsh treatment of the civilian populations in Belgium and the parts of France under German control. This provided a moral justification for the harsh terms of the treaty.
Why was the Marshall Plan important?
The treaty were designed to heal the wounds of World War II , not to punish the German people for Germany's part in starting world war II. Instead of creating the conditions for another war with Germany, the Marshall plan brought peace and created an ally of Germany.
Was the Marshall Plan justified?
The treaty could be justified but that did not make the treaty just. By imposing such harsh treatment of their opponent in world war I, the allies ensured that Germany would continue to be their enemy in world war II. The Marshall plan after World War II took the opposite tack.
Was the Treaty of Versailles fair?
The Treaty was fair in the sense that it could be justified by the Allied powers. It was not wise in that the harsh conditions of the treaty set the stage for world war II.